2010 MX Track Competition - Voting

[Voutare]

I'm with Shack, I'm not going to give rankings with no reasons behind them.

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 3
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 7
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 4
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 1
Badlands by Staydown - 5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 9
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 8
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 6


Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -
At first I didn't like it, it was awkward, fast, and didn't seem very fun. But after about 10 laps or so, I really noticed how well it was created. It just feels nice. It may be a little it too fast, but I like how it rides. It's fun, that's what counts.

Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 -
Way to slippery. To be honest, it was hard for me to ride it because it felt like too much mud. If fun matters, that's a big drawback. But I enjoyed the tracks jumps and feel, although a bit classic, 2 line, inside/outside.

AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -
Visually, amazing. Probably the best looking track, but I just can't get comfortable on it. It's extremely frusterating, with some sections that are really strange. (Holy Schmitt and finish are awkward) The decal ruts on the faces of some jumps were an eyesore, and had no real direction to them. Half the lines were at 30* from straight. The breaking bumps were odd, kicked funny, didn't feel right, but I'm somewhat nitpicking.

AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 1
DJ told me to. If I could vote Southwick in there, I'd give it 2nd, however that's bias (obviously), because I know how it flows.

Badlands by Staydown -
It felt polished. You definitely took your time and it feels really good. A few problems would be the width. It felt way to wide. And it was lacking a little in the detail in the displacement. It does ride good, but the style you made it is somewhat outdated. The tracks are supposed to be rougher now, and avoid the classic inside outside berms. That being said, I still loved riding the track.

Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -
Awkward. I'm not a fan of the l3dt style tracks, especially when 60% of the corners were blind, over a crest, and impossible to find a rut. I know you spent a lot of time on the disp map, but it just wasn't flowing. Your previous tracks were much better, with a flatter style terrain with obvious corners. Generally, if I can ride the track and figure out where it goes on the first lap, then it flows for me. I rode it countless times and I still don't have it down.

Green Valley MX by yFMX -
As always yFMX does phenominal work. The ruts were a little bit tight, and some of the jumps led you off to the side of the track with their natural flow, but it was a great disp map. Abit hard for a 250f, it feels like I'm riding a 80 on it. But if we had 450's, this would be the most fun track out. I wasn't too fond of the decals either. They were great, but I felt like they weren't as good as you can do. The rut decals looked out of place, like a white line marking the corner.

Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -
First track, right? I think it is, not entirely sure. But for a first track, it blows away most people have done. The disp was a little bit sloppy, and had a sort of 2008 MXS feel to it, and the decals could have been better, as I know what you can do with Photoshop. But for a first track, I'd be extremely proud of what you've accomplished.

Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN -
Leaps and bounds over your last contest track. I'd be pretty happy with the result. I liked the feel of the track, it doesn't quite feel up to par disp wise, but it rides good. I think more objects and environment would have helped. If you slow up the track and narrow it down, it'd feel much better.

[Mutt]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 7
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 8
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 5
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 2
Badlands by Staydown - 9
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 3
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 4
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 6
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1

[Arran34]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 5
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 4
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 3
Badlands by Staydown - 8
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 7
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 6
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1

[MXF_ATOC-x111]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 8
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 5
Badlands by Staydown - 4
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 6
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 7
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1

[yzmxer608]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 8
I liked a lot of the ideas on this track, but it was just too big and wide open for me. If it was scaled down I think it would be a lot more fun. The visuals weren't bad, the bales should have had collision though. I found myself going through them a lot.

Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
A lot of the sections seemed awkward to me, like the part coming back towards the finish with a few large rollers in a row. The track was pretty dark, because of that almost all of the bumps were invisible. The decals weren't horrible but seemed kind of boring (probably would have been better if they were lighter).

AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 3
Definitely a very fun track. I think it's about as close as you can get to the real track. Visuals are outstanding. My only complaint is sometimes when you are going slow it's very easy to slide out, it's not something I noticed too much in betas. One spot in particular is the finish area, I have to be very careful there. Oh and another thing, DJ, I'm calling the Aussie animal police on you. Barry pays good money to see the races, and he can't see the track behind a bunch of trees. Shame on you.

AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 7
I actually have a lot of fun on this track. It seems pretty close to the real one, I don't exactly remember it on TV so I can't comment much on how close it is. About the only major complaint is the traction and the berms, or the combination of them. It seems VERY easy to go over the berms here. I'm not sure if it's because they are rounder and smoother on top or the traction makes you slide out easily, but it's sketchy getting high on the berms. Wish the traction had a little more drag on it, I know it's not super deep sand but it didn't feel like much sand at all.

Badlands by Staydown - 5
The environment is incredible, absolutely no complaint there. It is pretty high speed and a lot of the jumps are really big, not the most realistic track ever but still pretty fun. The only thing I can say that would have made it better is smaller jumps or shorter sections.

Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 6
I enjoy this track. It has some really fun sections in it, a pretty realistic track. It almost seemed unfinished though, at lest the off track. There's not much going on, at least some more trees could have been added to make it look less bare. I like the decals, something different from what's been done before.

Green Valley MX by yFMX - 4
A very polished track for sure. Environment was perfect, the un-used sections are a good idea, the amount of shadingx2 work is incredible. I just wish there was more elevation changes, it's too flat for my tastes. That one step up before the nascar turn is almost too big, I've only made it once clean on my 125 so far. I think that section would have been better if the single before it was lower, or if one side of the face was lower on the step up so you could scrub it and not have to slam into the face if you don't make it like you do now.

Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 1

Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 2
This track had it all for me. I love the disp (all in the editor too), lots of elevation changes and offered a lot of split sections. There are only a few sections that are one lined, all of the others offer some benefit for going one way over the other (while still being equal in speed). The textures looked good, I like the shadingx2 work here too (Jack didn't get any cred?). I liked the setting/environment, not tons of objects but still seemed like there was enough.

[KTM57]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 2
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 4
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 6
Badlands by Staydown - 3
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 8
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 5
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 7
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1

[mxallan15]

i try comment my vote , but i'm not good speak english

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 7
( nice traction , fun , but too fast for simulation game )
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
( nice track , but i hate this traction and decal too dark , i'm not see bumps )
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -1
( no comment , i love )
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -2
( nice rut , nice traction , nice bumps , i love )
Badlands by Staydown -3
( too long jump , too fast , but too fun too , and very beautiful )
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -5
( i like bumps , and nice traction )
Green Valley MX by yFMX -4 ( hard but very nice )
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -8
( the track does not seem natural , and bumps too long )
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 6
(nice , but many curves identical )

[MXF_Popopski]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 7
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 4
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 5
Badlands by Staydown - 3
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 6
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 8
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 2

[Armadijl]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -6
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 -9
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -2
Badlands by Staydown -5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -8
Green Valley MX by yFMX -1
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -7
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN -4

[Juan357]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -4
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 5
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 6
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 3
Badlands by Staydown - 1
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 9
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 7
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 8

sry .. for the other post.. and ---- u factory

[Jr Dirt Doctor#489]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 3
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 8
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ - 6
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare - 1
Badlands by Staydown - 5
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 - 4
Green Valley MX by yFMX - 2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 - 9
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 7

[dani22]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 8
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 7
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -7
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -8
Badlands by Staydown -8
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -6
Green Valley MX by yFMX -2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -9
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 2

[checkerz]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 - 8
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 7
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -7
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -8
Badlands by Staydown -8
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -6
Green Valley MX by yFMX -2
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -9
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 2

You need to rate the tracks 1-9, with 1 being your favorite

[Motoboss]

Dang i screwed up ..too... Everything has to have a degree of difficulty in this game.Even freakin voting,lol..Kinda annoying really

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -7
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 4
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -3
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -2
Badlands by Staydown -9
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -6
Green Valley MX by yFMX -5
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -8
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 1

[Crossman35]

Alabama MX by Dearnhardtfan7 -8
Aldmoor by DJ_Diehl#777 - 9
AMA National: Millville 2008 by Checkerz448 & DJ -1
AMA Pro National: MX 338 by Voutare -5
Badlands by Staydown -4
Bartows Hill MX by FactoryBr21 -6
Green Valley MX by yFMX -3
Hillbrook Raceway by yzmxer608 -7
Sierra MX by PINNEDTOWIN - 2